103
103
Dec 3, 2013
12/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 103
favorite 0
quote 0
i think paul ryan will unveil. >> i think paul ryan will introduce a set of republican alternatives. >> not one huge bill. but a proposal for medicare, medicaid, individual market, corporate market and i think that will be in january and will help republican candidates say with more comfort and i think more truth that republicans do have a positive reform agenda in health care. >> let's get right to our panel. joining us now is mckay coppins of buzz feed.com. er irin carmon, and brian bought letter. >> there is so much psychological stuff here. bill crystal from the neo conservatives, this obsession with mission accomplished. all of this sort of george w. bush kind of iconography creeping back in. but not from democrats. from republicans. from the rupert murdochian "wall street journal." how did george w. bush go from being the beloved president who was the icon of the right to a dirty word? >> right. that's what's so fascinating here. this comes at a time when republicans are very happy to know that george w. bush's approval ratings, like all presidents after they leave office, have
i think paul ryan will unveil. >> i think paul ryan will introduce a set of republican alternatives. >> not one huge bill. but a proposal for medicare, medicaid, individual market, corporate market and i think that will be in january and will help republican candidates say with more comfort and i think more truth that republicans do have a positive reform agenda in health care. >> let's get right to our panel. joining us now is mckay coppins of buzz feed.com. er irin carmon,...
124
124
Mar 15, 2013
03/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 124
favorite 0
quote 0
>> sean: let's 0 go to paul ryan. he got high marks for personalizing the debts. >> we know with certainty a debt crisis is coming to america. this is not a question of if. it's a question of when. what is a debt crisis? it means we can't keep living beyond our means. it means we can't keep borrowing from our children's future. this -- our generation of americans, we're being selfish, we're taking from the next generation their future. we have a moral obligation to fix that. and if we have a debt crisis, those who get hurt the first and the worst are the ones who need government most, our seniors, the poor, the people living on the safety net. >> when he starts talking about the poor, democratic numbers shocked me, and the idea this is a moral issue, not just an economic issue. paul ryan is the best at this because he understands the details behind the budget and puts a personal face to it, which makes it incredible. >> sean: speculation 2016. way too early. but let's look at marco rubio and he wants to be part of the
>> sean: let's 0 go to paul ryan. he got high marks for personalizing the debts. >> we know with certainty a debt crisis is coming to america. this is not a question of if. it's a question of when. what is a debt crisis? it means we can't keep living beyond our means. it means we can't keep borrowing from our children's future. this -- our generation of americans, we're being selfish, we're taking from the next generation their future. we have a moral obligation to fix that. and if...
77
77
Apr 2, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 77
favorite 0
quote 0
thank you. >> thank you. >> greta: and congressman paul >> greta: and congressman paul ryan and ted cruz both hey america, even though she doesn't need them, >> greta: and congressman paul ryan and ted cruz both cheryl burke is cha-cha-ing in depend silhouette briefs for charity, to prove that with soft fabric and waistband, the best protection looks, fits, and feels just like underwear. get a free sample and try for yourself. a brand new start. your chance to rise and shine. with centurylink as your trusted technology partner, you can do just that. with our visionary cloud infrastructure, global broadband network and custom communications solutions, your business is more reliable - secure - agile. and with responsive, dedicated support, we help you shine every day of the week. >> okay, everyone, it's time to hash it out. this will make you do a double take. take a look at the tweet from congressman paul ryan. barack obama submits a balanced budget. really? check out the end. april fool's. and he used april fool's to jab about a budget. and he's not the only politician to give president
thank you. >> thank you. >> greta: and congressman paul >> greta: and congressman paul ryan and ted cruz both hey america, even though she doesn't need them, >> greta: and congressman paul ryan and ted cruz both cheryl burke is cha-cha-ing in depend silhouette briefs for charity, to prove that with soft fabric and waistband, the best protection looks, fits, and feels just like underwear. get a free sample and try for yourself. a brand new start. your chance to rise and...
59
59
Jan 29, 2013
01/13
by
MSNBC
tv
eye 59
favorite 0
quote 0
and it's not just john boehner and paul ryan. this is the narrative that's taken hold throughout all facets of the republican party. it's repeated ad nauseam on fox news. and you even hear it from some moderate conservative thinkers who ought to know better. obama is out to kill the wounded. now that republicans are down. he's not going to make any proposals that republicans might actually sign onto. instead, he's going to make them look bad on things like immigration. but it's interesting -- >> but that's not working, cynthia. >> -- supposed to be the party of personal responsibility. >> that narrative, gene, isn't working because quite clearly there's a bipartisan plan on immigration as we see today. anytime boehner, the speaker of the house, who i don't dislike, would come out for a background check on guns, just push one measure, if he could get that through the house, he'd be a leader on the newtown, connecticut, horror. he could be the leader. it would force harry reid to do the same. he doesn't have to be a victim. >> i th
and it's not just john boehner and paul ryan. this is the narrative that's taken hold throughout all facets of the republican party. it's repeated ad nauseam on fox news. and you even hear it from some moderate conservative thinkers who ought to know better. obama is out to kill the wounded. now that republicans are down. he's not going to make any proposals that republicans might actually sign onto. instead, he's going to make them look bad on things like immigration. but it's interesting --...
212
212
Jan 7, 2013
01/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 212
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan caught the book. senator ted cruz has it. holding the economy hostage to demand bungt cuts? a shutdown would mean americans would lose jobs, lose social security checks, veterans would lose benefits, medicare patients would be left waiting. joining me now is nia malika henderson and michelle cotter. thank you both for being here tonight. >> republicans are threatening to destroy the economy. is there anyway out of this? >> mitch mcconnell doesn't seem to be completely on board. >> but he wouldn't say no, either. >> you're right. he wouldn't rule it out completely or rule for his other people and say this is a real, real viable option. you know, i think what we see is a republican party that doesn't quite know what it's going to do in terms of bargaining around the debt ceiling limit. they've got a situation where th they're obviously talking about cuts. but one of the problems is people don't really wants cuts. and, also, i think the other reality is if you look at what's happened so far, i think we've cut out quite a bit. re
paul ryan caught the book. senator ted cruz has it. holding the economy hostage to demand bungt cuts? a shutdown would mean americans would lose jobs, lose social security checks, veterans would lose benefits, medicare patients would be left waiting. joining me now is nia malika henderson and michelle cotter. thank you both for being here tonight. >> republicans are threatening to destroy the economy. is there anyway out of this? >> mitch mcconnell doesn't seem to be completely on...
95
95
Oct 10, 2013
10/13
by
CNN
tv
eye 95
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan is not part of this defunding obama care. it was hatched by what i call the hell no caucus among house republicans and they are the ones saying to john boehner, you know, we don't want you to give in. so know you have this compromise you're talking about, a short term extension perhaps, but what i hear congress man king saying, which is so interesting to me is that maybe they could come up with some short-term compromise on the debt ceiling, because that's so dangerous, but in a way, still keep the government closed and not compromise on that and still tie obama care to that, so it's a little bit of have your cake and eat it, too. >> yeah, gloria borger, appreciate you, david king. >> you can follow me on twitter at anderson cooper. >>> the death of a young man named kendrick johnson, the official report calls it an accident. new evidence points to foul play and revelations about the treatment of his body are almost unspeakable. >>> another exclusive, another surv surviv survivor, the young woman in that photo is talking abou
paul ryan is not part of this defunding obama care. it was hatched by what i call the hell no caucus among house republicans and they are the ones saying to john boehner, you know, we don't want you to give in. so know you have this compromise you're talking about, a short term extension perhaps, but what i hear congress man king saying, which is so interesting to me is that maybe they could come up with some short-term compromise on the debt ceiling, because that's so dangerous, but in a way,...
51
51
Mar 10, 2013
03/13
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 51
favorite 0
quote 0
as i listen to paul ryan this morning, i am concerned. i think the republicans need to understand that there was an election. a lot of their proposals were part of this election. i think the public said something that was meaningful. i hope everybody will listen. >> we say thanks to our guests on newsmakers this morning. thank you for your time. >> it is my pleasure as always. i love to come here. i will not say how many of these cuts i have. -- cups i have. sometime at the ice cream in there when i'm not supposed to. >> will make sure you get some more. thanks to our guests. thanks a lot. >> thank you for doing this. i will see monday probably. >> thinks so much. -- and thanks so much. [captioning performed by national captioning institute] [captions copyright national cable satellite corp. 2013] >> coming up, a look at u.s. >> coming up, a look at u.s. policy toward
as i listen to paul ryan this morning, i am concerned. i think the republicans need to understand that there was an election. a lot of their proposals were part of this election. i think the public said something that was meaningful. i hope everybody will listen. >> we say thanks to our guests on newsmakers this morning. thank you for your time. >> it is my pleasure as always. i love to come here. i will not say how many of these cuts i have. -- cups i have. sometime at the ice...
128
128
tv
eye 128
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan is much more about getting those entitlement cuts and ted cruz is still talking obama care. >> and i read the op-ed that eric cantor, the majority leader in "the washington post." certainly he didn't make that the central issue. >> no. because now they have done this pivot and we saw the speaker go on the house floor this morning talking about obama care, talking about the glitches because they also have to get to that message because they haven't been doing that very effectively. so in all of this i think they kind of understand that they -- that their message has been unmuddled, it's been unpopular and in many ways they have promised conservatives something that they can't promise, defunding obama care. they knew all along, wolf, that could never happen. >> the president is not going to go along with that. >> of course. >> at 3:00 p.m., we're going to be covering the announcement of janet yellen if she's confirmed by the senate. she has a good chance of being confirmed. we'll see what happens in that fight. stand by for that. >>> frustration grows over the obama care websi
paul ryan is much more about getting those entitlement cuts and ted cruz is still talking obama care. >> and i read the op-ed that eric cantor, the majority leader in "the washington post." certainly he didn't make that the central issue. >> no. because now they have done this pivot and we saw the speaker go on the house floor this morning talking about obama care, talking about the glitches because they also have to get to that message because they haven't been doing that...
52
52
Oct 10, 2013
10/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 52
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan wrote it. i'm going to read it. >> washington insiders may like ryan's op-ed, which did not once mention the word "obama care." but the tea party is not. >> it seems like paul ryan has successfully, well, we'll say angered the right. >> with the tea party rebelling against paul ryan's plan, republican leadership is now poised to go to their old, white conservative base, the people showing up to rallies in tri-cornered hats, saying remember when we told you we would go against obama care? we decided to cut social security benefits instead. >> and you were at the meeting today at the white house with the president. what came of that meeting? >> well, he emphasized the fact that we cannot reward the republicans for shutting down the government. otherwise, they will do it again and again and again. we're talking about a six-week continuing resolution, keep the government open for six week. they're getting to extract the concessions on obama care, or as a condition of reopening it, what will they wa
paul ryan wrote it. i'm going to read it. >> washington insiders may like ryan's op-ed, which did not once mention the word "obama care." but the tea party is not. >> it seems like paul ryan has successfully, well, we'll say angered the right. >> with the tea party rebelling against paul ryan's plan, republican leadership is now poised to go to their old, white conservative base, the people showing up to rallies in tri-cornered hats, saying remember when we told you...
91
91
Mar 21, 2013
03/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 91
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> neil: this might be as far as paul ryan gets. his budget blueprint getting the green light in the house. a plan that would balance the budget, he says in ten years. of course does not sit well with democrats. remember this? >> the so-called budget wag -- was the republican platform. >> neil: we're cutting the growth of progress. are you saying -- >> not talking about -- >> spending -- congressman, do you think cutting spending should be a goal? yes or no? >> yes, it's how you cut it, of course. >> neil: all right. the presidential candidate herman cain. what too you make of this whole debate where we stand right now? >> it shows the democrats' hypocrisy. they believe in endless spending and endless taxation. they don't want to balance the budget. at least the ryan budget balances for the tenth year, and then from that point going forward. they don't want to balance the budget. and here's why -- >> neil: you know, you're a businessman. i'm sure you didn't do balanced budgets much beyond a couple of years, but ten years, i mean, re
. >> neil: this might be as far as paul ryan gets. his budget blueprint getting the green light in the house. a plan that would balance the budget, he says in ten years. of course does not sit well with democrats. remember this? >> the so-called budget wag -- was the republican platform. >> neil: we're cutting the growth of progress. are you saying -- >> not talking about -- >> spending -- congressman, do you think cutting spending should be a goal? yes or no?...
97
97
Mar 21, 2013
03/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 97
favorite 0
quote 0
interestingly that's not what paul ryan and others want. they want to kill the dragon with a balanced budget as quickly as possible, don't they? >> right. the idea of balancing the budget over x years is really -- >> in his case ten years. in rand paul's case four or five years. >> so is, a, antithey cal to what they need to be concerned about. in fact, anytime we've ever achieved a sustainable budget packet that's brought the debt down as a share of the economy, it's economic growth has been a key component. all of that said, there are pressures from health care costs in the long term, and we do have to deal with them, but interestingly, even there, there's some hope, because the dragon -- that part of the dragon is actually shrinken a bit. the congressional budget office has pulled down their long-term forecast for the growth of medicare and medicaid by half a trillion over the next ten years. it doesn't mean we're out of the woods, but some of the cost savings issues that will be so important to solving the real debt crisis are actually
interestingly that's not what paul ryan and others want. they want to kill the dragon with a balanced budget as quickly as possible, don't they? >> right. the idea of balancing the budget over x years is really -- >> in his case ten years. in rand paul's case four or five years. >> so is, a, antithey cal to what they need to be concerned about. in fact, anytime we've ever achieved a sustainable budget packet that's brought the debt down as a share of the economy, it's economic...
41
41
Jan 29, 2013
01/13
by
MSNBC
tv
eye 41
favorite 0
quote 0
and paul ryan boxed it. he is against that. and if you remember from that interview, he did not give a single specific about a tax break he wants to end, and he talked about cutting entitlements. >> he is up front saying no more revenue. i mean, that's their position on that. now, they've backed off the debt limit. now they're backing off a government shutdown. can problem get them to back off sequester as well? or do you believe what he says they really want that? i think he could. here is the i think important point. the business community in america, particularly the financial community, to my great disappointment, they were many of them supportive of president obama in 2008. he was rationale and helped get the country out of the terrible crisis they engendered. we had a bipartisan cooperation with the bush administration to do that, weight-2009. then because we passed a consumer reform bill, they overwhelmingly supported the republicans. i've said to some of them you are supporting people who are following policies you know
and paul ryan boxed it. he is against that. and if you remember from that interview, he did not give a single specific about a tax break he wants to end, and he talked about cutting entitlements. >> he is up front saying no more revenue. i mean, that's their position on that. now, they've backed off the debt limit. now they're backing off a government shutdown. can problem get them to back off sequester as well? or do you believe what he says they really want that? i think he could. here...
80
80
Mar 22, 2013
03/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 80
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan says no. >> at least budgets are passing around here for a change. the government's going to have to learn to do more with less, it's not the government's money, it's the people's money. >> the senate democrats are considering a number of balances ever-- >> and house committee chair paul ryan telling us republicans and democrats are still world's apart. well, that is an understatement. we saw that just an hour ago. the democratic-led senate defeating the ryan house budget 40-59. so is there any hope left? here is congressman paul ryan. >> great to see you. >> great it to see you again. >> greta: i want to talk about the budget that passed today, i imagine you're happy. >> we're very happy. we passed a balanced budget and it's important we owe the country a reasonable plan and grows the economy. balancing the budget is not just a statistical exercise it's the necessary means to a healthier economy, it creates more jobs and helps people keep more of hard earned money and a contrast to the other budgets that are passing. at least budgets are passing her
paul ryan says no. >> at least budgets are passing around here for a change. the government's going to have to learn to do more with less, it's not the government's money, it's the people's money. >> the senate democrats are considering a number of balances ever-- >> and house committee chair paul ryan telling us republicans and democrats are still world's apart. well, that is an understatement. we saw that just an hour ago. the democratic-led senate defeating the ryan house...
95
95
Feb 3, 2013
02/13
by
WJLA
tv
eye 95
favorite 0
quote 0
at this stage, paul ryan says the sequester is going g to happen. if pau ryan says it, that is a big deal. he campaignened sayiying thehe sequester should not a and cannot happen. >> at the e book of lisists party, people spend a lot of timime talking about ngress. everyone was talking about it because they are discouraged foror what wld mean for r the washington area. bodyhinks theyy will get a de. do you see any reason for hope? >> i see reason to not be helpful, especially after the paul ryan comments. he sai republicans w will nonot make compromises to stop i ththe compromisese the democrats want our new r revenues and tax loopopholes. the e fact that paul ryan and republicans have said the'rere willing to see this happepen, they will not agreeee to new revenues. it suggests there e is very little room for agreement. >> is it inevitable we will see cuts in defense spending one of the reasosons the gdp shrank is we're spending l less money figing wars overseas. i am not a big fan of spending money unnecessarily on defen butt this region wildefini
at this stage, paul ryan says the sequester is going g to happen. if pau ryan says it, that is a big deal. he campaignened sayiying thehe sequester should not a and cannot happen. >> at the e book of lisists party, people spend a lot of timime talking about ngress. everyone was talking about it because they are discouraged foror what wld mean for r the washington area. bodyhinks theyy will get a de. do you see any reason for hope? >> i see reason to not be helpful, especially after...
96
96
Mar 17, 2013
03/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 96
favorite 0
quote 0
could paul ryan be dealing with anger from his own party? i'll ask one of the startest business minds next. >> during the break, tweet me, let me know if you think it's time for republicans to move past the ryan budget, or do you think with the election aside, it's obama and the democratic who need to move. to the globaln we call the internet of everything. ♪ it's going to be amazing. and exciting. and maybe, most remarkably, not that far away. we're going to wake the world up. and watch, with eyes wide, as it gets to work. cisco. tomorrow starts here. for those nights when it's more than a bad dream, be ready. for the times you need to double-check the temperature on the thermometer, be ready. for high fever, nothing works faster or lasts longer. be ready with children's motrin. or lasts longer. it's not what you think. it's a phoenix with 4 wheels. it's a hawk with night vision goggles. it's marching to the beat of a different drum. and where beauty meets brains. it's big ideas with smaller footprints. and knowing there's always more in
could paul ryan be dealing with anger from his own party? i'll ask one of the startest business minds next. >> during the break, tweet me, let me know if you think it's time for republicans to move past the ryan budget, or do you think with the election aside, it's obama and the democratic who need to move. to the globaln we call the internet of everything. ♪ it's going to be amazing. and exciting. and maybe, most remarkably, not that far away. we're going to wake the world up. and...
57
57
Mar 10, 2013
03/13
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 57
favorite 0
quote 0
i heard paul ryan said we had to repeal obamacare. that is part of his budget. it would be a bad idea. we're already seeing the benefits of health care reform throughout the country. the notion of repealing it now is a non-starter. >> this is something that was suggested that the president put on the table during the fiscal cliff negotiations that upset a lot of house democrats. is that something that you could support as part of a broader package? >> we need to look at it there are problems. the people who are mostly hurt by the change our older seniors. that means more women than men. the president has always said we will have to modify its some way if we go forth. it is not easy to modify. we need to sit down and have a broader discretion. i think we will discuss entitlements. social security is the part of the problem we face. what is happening with health care costs is interesting. when republicans talk about what is happening with the medicare, you have reported on it, the cost increase today for health care has been going down. the same is true of medicar
i heard paul ryan said we had to repeal obamacare. that is part of his budget. it would be a bad idea. we're already seeing the benefits of health care reform throughout the country. the notion of repealing it now is a non-starter. >> this is something that was suggested that the president put on the table during the fiscal cliff negotiations that upset a lot of house democrats. is that something that you could support as part of a broader package? >> we need to look at it there are...
105
105
Mar 13, 2013
03/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 105
favorite 0
quote 0
what do you think of paul ryan's budget. log on to our special companion site hannity live. ♪ [ male announcer ] you've reached the age where you don't back down from a challenge. this is the age of knowing how to make things happen. sowhy let erectile dysfunction get in your way? talk to your doctor about viagra. 20 million men already have. ask your doctor if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take viagra if you take nitrates for chest pain; it may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. side effects include headache, flushing, upset stomach, and abnormal vision. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than four hours. stop taking viagra and call your doctor right away if you experience a sudden decrease or loss in vision or hearing. this is the age of taking action. viagra. talk to your doctor. executor of efficiency. you can spot an amateur from a mile away... while going shoeless and metal-free in seconds. and you...rent from national. because only national lets yo
what do you think of paul ryan's budget. log on to our special companion site hannity live. ♪ [ male announcer ] you've reached the age where you don't back down from a challenge. this is the age of knowing how to make things happen. sowhy let erectile dysfunction get in your way? talk to your doctor about viagra. 20 million men already have. ask your doctor if your heart is healthy enough for sex. do not take viagra if you take nitrates for chest pain; it may cause an unsafe drop in blood...
58
58
Sep 23, 2013
09/13
by
MSNBC
tv
eye 58
favorite 0
quote 0
. >>> coming up, congressman paul ryan pens another book. we will discuss the new book of paul just ahead. check it out. i can't believe your mom has a mom cave! today i have new campbell's chunky spicy chicken quesadilla soup. she gives me chunky before every game. i'm very souperstitious. haha, that's a good one! haha! [ male announcer ] campbell's chunky soup. it fills you up right. how old is the oldest person you've known? we gave people a sticker and had them show us. we learned a lot of us have known someone who's lived well into their 90s. and that's a great thing. but even though we're living longer, one thing that hasn't changed much is the official retirement age. ♪ the question is how do you make sure you have the money you need to enjoy all of these years. ♪ yeah... try new alka seltzer fruit chews. they work fast on heartburn and taste awesome. these are good. told ya! i'm feeling better already. [ male announcer ] new alka seltzer fruits chews. enjoy the relief! you're not linda. i'm filling in for officer owens. she used
. >>> coming up, congressman paul ryan pens another book. we will discuss the new book of paul just ahead. check it out. i can't believe your mom has a mom cave! today i have new campbell's chunky spicy chicken quesadilla soup. she gives me chunky before every game. i'm very souperstitious. haha, that's a good one! haha! [ male announcer ] campbell's chunky soup. it fills you up right. how old is the oldest person you've known? we gave people a sticker and had them show us. we learned...
101
101
Mar 13, 2013
03/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 101
favorite 0
quote 0
ryan they didn't scare the seniors, they went with paul ryan and okay with his budget cuts and shackle the future. >> eric, let me break the news to you, the president won florida. and let me just say-- >> yeah, the president won florida, but he didn't win the seniors. >> this is the real story behind the republican strategy, sean. republicans somehow think, oh, we did pretty well with the seniors and old folks and therefore it's okay to go after medicare. >> sean: wait a minute, only one person to cut medicare, that was obama. we've got to go. >> you look at paul ryan's budget, gentlemen. >> sean: coming up next, while the president is busy charming folks in washington, north korea is threatening to carry out a nuclear attack on american soil and now hamas is threatening the president and they say they'll declare war against the united states if the president does, well, this one thing. we'll explain with rudy guiliani next. [ male announcer ] it's simple physics... a body at rest tends to stay at rest... while a body in motion tends to stay in motion. staying active can actually ease
ryan they didn't scare the seniors, they went with paul ryan and okay with his budget cuts and shackle the future. >> eric, let me break the news to you, the president won florida. and let me just say-- >> yeah, the president won florida, but he didn't win the seniors. >> this is the real story behind the republican strategy, sean. republicans somehow think, oh, we did pretty well with the seniors and old folks and therefore it's okay to go after medicare. >> sean: wait...
125
125
May 26, 2013
05/13
by
CSPAN
tv
eye 125
favorite 0
quote 1
we begin with representative paul ryan at benedictine college. and then nancy pelosi at the university of baltimore law school. after that, peter king speaks at st. john's university. later, we will hear from elizabeth warren. and flores at texas a&m mark warner at george mason university. wisconsin representative and 2012 vice presidential candidate paul ryan gave the 2013 commencement address at benedictine college in kansas. this is about 20 minutes. [applause] >> thank you. thank you. president, alex, where are you, alex? thank you for rekindling that feeling i had at the republican national convention after i followed condoleezza rice. thanks a lot. i appreciate that. [laughter] the four i want to get into the commencement, i have heard so many good things about benedictine college. my friend,, who spoke last year, yup and told me about this gold -- called me up and told me about the school. he said you are a tightknit and broad-minded, small sized and bighearted. i have spent a little bit of time here. p90x this morning. i got to do dinner
we begin with representative paul ryan at benedictine college. and then nancy pelosi at the university of baltimore law school. after that, peter king speaks at st. john's university. later, we will hear from elizabeth warren. and flores at texas a&m mark warner at george mason university. wisconsin representative and 2012 vice presidential candidate paul ryan gave the 2013 commencement address at benedictine college in kansas. this is about 20 minutes. [applause] >> thank you. thank...
105
105
Oct 10, 2013
10/13
by
CNN
tv
eye 105
favorite 0
quote 0
ted cruz said no. >> but you look at paul ryan. i mean, i'd call that a kind of wilted olive branch. >> a wilted olive branch. >> it was an olive branch. he was saying here are things we can do that maybe will get us out of this. he didn't mention the affordable care act. and one of the problems, one of the reasons i can share a little bit of per respective both side. one of the reasons the democrats in the senate are so adamant about this is they felt like they've already given at the office. harry reid made a deal with john boehner in early september. we're going to take the lower number on the sequester number on the continuing resolution. we hate it. we don't like it. but okay, to get it done. and then the speaker couldn't get the votes. >> and the democrats said to me, the speaker can't deliver a pizza. they're very annoyed with that. >> but he's doing his best. i'm sure he didn't go into his caucus saying, don't let me do this. >> senator let me ask you a question. this has become -- i asked senator durbin about this today, t
ted cruz said no. >> but you look at paul ryan. i mean, i'd call that a kind of wilted olive branch. >> a wilted olive branch. >> it was an olive branch. he was saying here are things we can do that maybe will get us out of this. he didn't mention the affordable care act. and one of the problems, one of the reasons i can share a little bit of per respective both side. one of the reasons the democrats in the senate are so adamant about this is they felt like they've already...
989
989
Mar 12, 2013
03/13
by
CSPAN
quote
eye 989
favorite 0
quote 3
. >> the good people outside this process might be watching and saying, well, paul ryan did this last year -- >> and the year before that and the year before that. >> and he was on the ticket, ran on this, pretty darn close. president obama ran on what he called the balanced approach, raising taxes on the wealthy and his medicare and social security position. he won that election. house republicans lost seats in the house, got one million fewer votes than democrats. senate republicans lost seats in the senate. people outside this process might wonder if elections have consequences on the budgeting process. do they? >> so the question is, the election did not go our way -- believe me, i know what that feels like. that means we surrender our principles? that means we stop believing in what we believe in? look, whether the country intended it or not, we have the second-largest house majority we have had since world war roman to -- since world war ii. we need to put up our vision. we think we owe the gadget -- we owe the country a balanced budget, solutions to the problems that are plagui
. >> the good people outside this process might be watching and saying, well, paul ryan did this last year -- >> and the year before that and the year before that. >> and he was on the ticket, ran on this, pretty darn close. president obama ran on what he called the balanced approach, raising taxes on the wealthy and his medicare and social security position. he won that election. house republicans lost seats in the house, got one million fewer votes than democrats. senate...
991
991
Dec 11, 2013
12/13
by
CSPAN
quote
eye 991
favorite 0
quote 3
paul ryan and the senate budget committee chair patty murray for a joint announcement the agreement. this is 15 minutes. >> good evening. i am happy to report that senator murray and i have reached an agreement. we've been talking all year. and this week that hard work of the two of us sitting down and talking to each other all year has paid off. first, it started because we passed budgets. and senator murray deserves credit for passing a budget through the senate. that got the ball rolling so that the two of us started talking. and the reason we're here tonight is to explain what we've agreed to. this bill reduces the deficit by $23 billion. and it does not raise taxes. and it cuts spending in a smarter way. from the outset, we knew that if we forced each other to compromise a core principle he would get nowhere. that is why we decided to focus on where the common ground is. so that's what we've done. that means to me a budget agreement that reduces the deficit without raising taxes and replaces some of the arbitrary, across-the-board spending cuts with smarter, permanent reforms th
paul ryan and the senate budget committee chair patty murray for a joint announcement the agreement. this is 15 minutes. >> good evening. i am happy to report that senator murray and i have reached an agreement. we've been talking all year. and this week that hard work of the two of us sitting down and talking to each other all year has paid off. first, it started because we passed budgets. and senator murray deserves credit for passing a budget through the senate. that got the ball...
1,145
1.1K
Mar 12, 2013
03/13
by
CSPAN
quote
eye 1,145
favorite 0
quote 3
live now to capitol hill to house budget committee chair paul ryan as he releases his budget for 2014. >> good morning, everybody. what we have here is the house budget committee am a republican majority, putting out yet again a budget that addresses america's needs. a budget that balances the budget. it is a path to prosperity, a responsible balanced budget. we believe we owe the american people a balanced budget, and for the third straight year we have delivered rate we balance this budget in just 10 years. this is a document, a plan that balances the budget in 10 years. the house budget committee has spent the last several weeks working together with each other just like families and businesses do around the country. we have been assembling a budget so that we can make sure our country can live within its means. it is a reasonable goal, balancing the budget, and we keep -- we cannot keep spending money we don't have. that is the basic acknowledgment, when you are budgeting like families and businesses do, that you cannot continue to kick the can down the road and spend money we don
live now to capitol hill to house budget committee chair paul ryan as he releases his budget for 2014. >> good morning, everybody. what we have here is the house budget committee am a republican majority, putting out yet again a budget that addresses america's needs. a budget that balances the budget. it is a path to prosperity, a responsible balanced budget. we believe we owe the american people a balanced budget, and for the third straight year we have delivered rate we balance this...
114
114
Mar 17, 2013
03/13
by
FBC
tv
eye 114
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan by the way has been a leader since the '80s. we have a president saying now you my goal is not to balance the budget just for balance sake. how do you act and get a fiscal responsibility into government with a president like that? >> and john, unfortunately, hold on a second, mark. we haven't heard from john in awhile. unfortunately you are not the leading the republicans right now. somebody, paul ryan put forth a plan that says it is insufficient. if it is insufficient in your eyes where do republicans go? >> where do they go? it is not the ryan way. this is not how you get back into the majority and i want to make a basic point. >> please. >> governments do not create jobs. they only can create jobs in so far as they take resources from the private sector. >> got to get it some where. >> we prefer the jobs from microsoft. >> only happened once in the bible according to my reading. thank you, gang. appreciate it. first and last word interest john. is work wiping you out? no worries. some losses are seaing take a nap on the job.
paul ryan by the way has been a leader since the '80s. we have a president saying now you my goal is not to balance the budget just for balance sake. how do you act and get a fiscal responsibility into government with a president like that? >> and john, unfortunately, hold on a second, mark. we haven't heard from john in awhile. unfortunately you are not the leading the republicans right now. somebody, paul ryan put forth a plan that says it is insufficient. if it is insufficient in your...
82
82
Dec 10, 2013
12/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 82
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan's been very clear about that. we need not just short term, but long-term solutions. >> do you feel that paul ryan has sold you out? you saw him at this press conference. he was not saying the things he was saying now. do you feel like paul ryan has sold you out? >> i will not say that, but at the end of the day, spending is going up. if republicans and conservatives have said for years we've been spending too much money, bipartisan usually scares us. that means more spending at the end of the day. will let me ask you a similar question. paul ryan rarely gets credit for work across the aisle, and he does it frequently. >> i give him credit for that. for trying to hammer something out. it may or may not fly. >> all we hear is the intransgent republicans. >> i think he deserves credit. this is not ease tee to sell to his own conference. i don't know whether we'll get there. we're going to lose a substantial number of republicans. we're going to lose a substantial number of democrats if we what we hear about the bill
paul ryan's been very clear about that. we need not just short term, but long-term solutions. >> do you feel that paul ryan has sold you out? you saw him at this press conference. he was not saying the things he was saying now. do you feel like paul ryan has sold you out? >> i will not say that, but at the end of the day, spending is going up. if republicans and conservatives have said for years we've been spending too much money, bipartisan usually scares us. that means more...
106
106
Dec 12, 2013
12/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 106
favorite 0
quote 0
if paul ryan gives something his blessing, it brings the votes. apparently not always chls i want to talk about the breakdown of alliances. supporters at the aforementioned john boehner, paul ryan who brokered the deal, eric cantor, the traditionalist wing of the party. on the other side seeing a deal called pragmatist. mcconnell facing a primary in kentucky, john cornyn and john thum coming out against it. is this idea of a republican civil war real or see people going to their camps? >> i think the civil war is real. i think folks like boehner and ryan are living in the real world when it comes to politics. they saw the recent shutdown, they got clobbered. they decided no more suicide mission. it's a measure of how far we've fallen as a society that people are congratulated for coming to an agreement on the deal that's going to hurt a lot of people. that's both parties. it's bizarre to me. >> it is a sort of a new normal, alex. lets go through quickly what is in this deal causing this rift. if you look at it from the outside looking in, isn't a
if paul ryan gives something his blessing, it brings the votes. apparently not always chls i want to talk about the breakdown of alliances. supporters at the aforementioned john boehner, paul ryan who brokered the deal, eric cantor, the traditionalist wing of the party. on the other side seeing a deal called pragmatist. mcconnell facing a primary in kentucky, john cornyn and john thum coming out against it. is this idea of a republican civil war real or see people going to their camps? >>...
112
112
Oct 11, 2013
10/13
by
CNN
tv
eye 112
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan, he's going to be i addressing this conference as well. his op-ed in the "wall street journal" outlining the initiative toss des to deal wit debt ceiling, no mention of all of obama care in that article. what do we expect to hear today? >> we certainly expect him to talk about the negotiations of standing by your values. but we won't see paul ryan here, as you said, in fact, a family research council spokesman told me that paul ryan was very clear for the past couple of weeks that if there was a government shutdown that in fact he would not be able to come here. they worked out a deal. they will do a five-minute have. remember, paul ryan is known within the party of being the big thinker, as being somebody who understands the budget whp while he might talk about issues, social conservative issues or mention them, in paul ryan's really, his go-to is being able to balance the budget and to talking about policier shus that a lot of people can't do. i think that's what we'll hear from him today. >> clearly emerging as a major player in this ef
paul ryan, he's going to be i addressing this conference as well. his op-ed in the "wall street journal" outlining the initiative toss des to deal wit debt ceiling, no mention of all of obama care in that article. what do we expect to hear today? >> we certainly expect him to talk about the negotiations of standing by your values. but we won't see paul ryan here, as you said, in fact, a family research council spokesman told me that paul ryan was very clear for the past couple...
119
119
Apr 2, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 119
favorite 0
quote 0
take a look at the tweet from congressman paul ryan. barack obama submits a balanced budget. really? check out the end. april fool's. and he used april fool's to jab about a budget. and he's not the only politician to give president obama grief. senator cruz tweeting out a picture photo shopped, if you like the plan you can keep it with the hashtag repeal obamacare and it's doubtful he enjoyed senator cruz's tweet, but you never know. >> and macy's catalog typo knocks a $1,500 necklace down to $47. the price was $479 and some got the bargain price. maybe i'll start shopping through the macy's category more often. and this video is insane and the new york post tweeting watch. woman barely escapes train after dropping the phone on the tracks. we're not going to talk about it. we'll watch it. (scream (screams) >> amazing. the woman was not hurt. and does this picture look a tad bit odd to you? the bunny is not wearing a helmet. the easter bunny is pulled over in california when he was not wearing a helmet. and luckily they issued him a warning not a citation. an orphaned polar b
take a look at the tweet from congressman paul ryan. barack obama submits a balanced budget. really? check out the end. april fool's. and he used april fool's to jab about a budget. and he's not the only politician to give president obama grief. senator cruz tweeting out a picture photo shopped, if you like the plan you can keep it with the hashtag repeal obamacare and it's doubtful he enjoyed senator cruz's tweet, but you never know. >> and macy's catalog typo knocks a $1,500 necklace...
73
73
Nov 20, 2013
11/13
by
CSPAN3
tv
eye 73
favorite 0
quote 0
ryan for about an hour. >> paul, welcome. congressman, thank you for being here. we know you've been a friend of the ceo council before and it's great to have you here. i want to bounce off you at least at the start a couple of things the president said and get you to respond. he spoke in strong terms about the problems we've had with governing by crisis referring to the shutdown and so on. he expressed some optimism about this budget round in particular avoiding repetition of what happened the late unpleasantness. can you tell us right now here that there will not be another shutdown or another debt limit -- >> i'm comfortable with saying that. whether or not we come to an an agreement or we just have a continuing resolution that just keeps going, either one of those two scenarios will prevail and we will not have a government shutdown. the debt limit is later on. we don't know the timing of that. i don't know if you had jack lew here or not -- >> we did. >> he was able to do more extraordinary measures. that could be into t
ryan for about an hour. >> paul, welcome. congressman, thank you for being here. we know you've been a friend of the ceo council before and it's great to have you here. i want to bounce off you at least at the start a couple of things the president said and get you to respond. he spoke in strong terms about the problems we've had with governing by crisis referring to the shutdown and so on. he expressed some optimism about this budget round in particular avoiding repetition of what...
48
48
Jan 17, 2013
01/13
by
MSNBC
tv
eye 48
favorite 0
quote 0
you know, paul ryan? the guy who lost in november? we'll go inside the gop's big unity conference tonight. but, first, governor rick scott did everything he could to suppress voters in florida. but, today, he's suppressing his own memory. this is one you need to hear. you're watching politics nation on msnbc. ♪ [ female announcer ] he could be the one. soulmate. husband. loving father to your children. but first you've got to get him to say, "hello." new crest 3d white arctic fresh toothpaste. use it with these 3d white products, and whiten your teeth in just 2 days. what will a 3d white smile do for you? new crest 3d white toothpaste. life opens up when you do. what's good for the pot... is even better for the cup. new single serve cafe collections from maxwell house. now available for use in the keurig k-cup brewer. always good to the last drop. ♪ [ male announcer ] this is karen and jeremiah. they don't know it yet, but they're gonna fall in love, get married, have a couple of kids, [ children laughing ] move to the country, an
you know, paul ryan? the guy who lost in november? we'll go inside the gop's big unity conference tonight. but, first, governor rick scott did everything he could to suppress voters in florida. but, today, he's suppressing his own memory. this is one you need to hear. you're watching politics nation on msnbc. ♪ [ female announcer ] he could be the one. soulmate. husband. loving father to your children. but first you've got to get him to say, "hello." new crest 3d white arctic fresh...
114
114
Apr 10, 2013
04/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 114
favorite 0
quote 0
i was in a session with paul ryan and he 45 minutes and he's hopeful that maybe there would be common ground on tax reform and maybe they would find something with the president moving forward. but pretty much everybody in washington understands it is unlikely it is a grand bargain and paul ryan said he didn't think there would be a grand bargain and the fact that the president didn't go on the, there would not be a grand bargain. >> we'll need a bigger boat. obama is offering the most minuscule change that cpi recommended by every commission in the last 20 years. it is obvious . a correction and the whole point much indexing social security with inflation and a way to protect seniors . what this does, every year it protects them and without intending to adds on to that. this is correcting and as i said. if you get a $2000 check from the government it removes a $5 and that is devastating social security. we will end up like cyprus. >> and i asked several different way to jay carny and they are tough interviews to do in a short period of time. didn't get a lot of answers tompt your poi
i was in a session with paul ryan and he 45 minutes and he's hopeful that maybe there would be common ground on tax reform and maybe they would find something with the president moving forward. but pretty much everybody in washington understands it is unlikely it is a grand bargain and paul ryan said he didn't think there would be a grand bargain and the fact that the president didn't go on the, there would not be a grand bargain. >> we'll need a bigger boat. obama is offering the most...
1,027
1.0K
Oct 25, 2013
10/13
by
COM
tv
eye 1,027
favorite 0
quote 0
give it to paul ryan and ted cruz. give it to them, no, they know. can you stick around. we'll be back withes >> jon: that's our show. join us tomorrow at 11:00. here it is your moment of zen. >> there's new and definitive evidence tonight that americans have wa ( cheers and applause ) hello it's 11:59 and 59 seconds. this happenedded on the internet today. that is a teacher's assistantt university of iowa. meant to e-mail her students math problems but instead sent them her homemade porn cyb erp sex gif-- yes, i say gif with a hard g. hi class i attached the solutions for 76 and 78 in the e-mail. best. that looks like the solution to 69. i know i went to the easy one first. please respond to our e-mail as one of our students after watching her homemade porn, dierk go. >> unsubscribe? ( laughter ) >> james adomian. >> do we solve forxxx? >> mike lawrence. >> i stared at this all night and i still couldn't finish. ( laughter ) ( applause ) >> well done. it's time to start "@midnight." ( cheers and applause ) >> twok "@midnight" where we swim into the the abyss of social me
give it to paul ryan and ted cruz. give it to them, no, they know. can you stick around. we'll be back withes >> jon: that's our show. join us tomorrow at 11:00. here it is your moment of zen. >> there's new and definitive evidence tonight that americans have wa ( cheers and applause ) hello it's 11:59 and 59 seconds. this happenedded on the internet today. that is a teacher's assistantt university of iowa. meant to e-mail her students math problems but instead sent them her...
314
314
Feb 14, 2013
02/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 314
favorite 0
quote 0
chris christie is above paul ryan. overseeing the nation's money is facing tough questions about how he has over seen his own money. chief of staff jack lieu is beginning the process become treasury secretary. they have details of what went down on the hill. the finance committee top republican had a possible conflict of interest. >> he would be saying do as i say not as i did. >> 945,000 dollar bonus he received. >> explain why it would be morally acceptable to take post domain dollars out of a company that was insolvent and about to receive a billion dollars of tax payer support. >> it was a manner of people who did the same kind of thing i did in the industry. i was compensated for my work. i will leaf for others to judge. >> dakota cu baucus talked abou in a well-known tax haven. >> i don't know why it was organized. i was not involved in setting up the fund. >> did you pay taxes on that investment? >> i reported all income related to the investment on my tax forms. i paid all of my taxes. >> he went on to say he l
chris christie is above paul ryan. overseeing the nation's money is facing tough questions about how he has over seen his own money. chief of staff jack lieu is beginning the process become treasury secretary. they have details of what went down on the hill. the finance committee top republican had a possible conflict of interest. >> he would be saying do as i say not as i did. >> 945,000 dollar bonus he received. >> explain why it would be morally acceptable to take post...
92
92
Mar 13, 2013
03/13
by
FBC
tv
eye 92
favorite 0
quote 0
paul ryan said basically not so charming. the president making certain democrats know that he may be in this same room with republicans from time to time, but he is not really negotiating. >> if their position is we can't do any revenue or we can only do revenue if we get medicare or get social security or get medicaid, if that is the position that we're probably not going to be able to get a deal. lou: getting social security and medicare? mr. president, such language. in your second term? you have been doing this for four years and that's the best you could do with the rhetoric? we have been led by your performance to expect more and better by now. the truth is, the truth, as you well know, republicans are not getting a thing. and we will show you just how that works. it is really simple and will set your mind at ease, mr. president. the ryan budget does not get anything. it raises spending. not a dime. not a dime. it raises spending cuts is not as quickly as current law. the budget committee chairman would increase spendin
paul ryan said basically not so charming. the president making certain democrats know that he may be in this same room with republicans from time to time, but he is not really negotiating. >> if their position is we can't do any revenue or we can only do revenue if we get medicare or get social security or get medicaid, if that is the position that we're probably not going to be able to get a deal. lou: getting social security and medicare? mr. president, such language. in your second...
76
76
Oct 10, 2013
10/13
by
CNNW
tv
eye 76
favorite 0
quote 0
. >> paul ryan now did this op ed, did not mention obama care as one of the things that would have to be on the table. >> though he did mention entitlement reform in general. and he counts obama care as part of entitlement reform. but the tone is different today from both sides. i will tell you than it's been the previous seven days. i'm beginning to seat ice start to melt. the president is giving on accepting a short-term solution. he's also giving on negotiating even if it's post-facto. and i think the republicans are also beginning to give. and for the first time we saw today something which is extraordinary, which was the house minority leader, nancy pelosi and her leadership team called over to the republican leadership team and there was a bipartisan meeting of leadership in the house of representatives today. i don't know when the last time woe saw that happen, dana. >> talk about the soft bigotry of low expectations. there was a meeting. that's wow, that's great. >> it is wow. i sent dana an e-mail and said girl, run, because lightning's going to strike. >> something very inte
. >> paul ryan now did this op ed, did not mention obama care as one of the things that would have to be on the table. >> though he did mention entitlement reform in general. and he counts obama care as part of entitlement reform. but the tone is different today from both sides. i will tell you than it's been the previous seven days. i'm beginning to seat ice start to melt. the president is giving on accepting a short-term solution. he's also giving on negotiating even if it's...
64
64
Mar 26, 2013
03/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 64
favorite 0
quote 0
or paul ryan budget. and there was very little news made, very little discussion of the house caucus budget which in its own way should be the flag around which democrats rally, given the extreme opposition. >> the progressive caucus budget is the most responsible budget that's been presented. i think even more than patty murray's budget. the senate democratic budget. but you're right. it doesn't get attention, because inside the beltway, the fixation is on deficit reduction, and that's not just among conservatives but centrists who somehow buy the idea that government is going to crush us if we don't immediately and drastically cut now. i don't think they want to cut as much as rand paul wants to cut. and you were right to highlight that part of his budget, increasing the retirement age and privatizing medicare, because i think that's the part of his budget that's going to really crash his 2016 hopes. but to get back to 2014, you know, it's going to be up to obama, particularly, to lead the charge. he's
or paul ryan budget. and there was very little news made, very little discussion of the house caucus budget which in its own way should be the flag around which democrats rally, given the extreme opposition. >> the progressive caucus budget is the most responsible budget that's been presented. i think even more than patty murray's budget. the senate democratic budget. but you're right. it doesn't get attention, because inside the beltway, the fixation is on deficit reduction, and that's...
138
138
Dec 17, 2013
12/13
by
MSNBCW
tv
eye 138
favorite 0
quote 0
here's what paul ryan told a wisconsin radio station. by the way, here he is talking back home which is important. here he is not exactly backing up his leader. >> i don't think it's that serious. i think john got -- his emotions got ahead of him a little bit. i credit the tea party with helping us get our mojo back. getting conservativism back in the party. >> here's a paul ryan skipping off the reservation here. c >> i think john got his irish up. he was frustrated that these groups came out in opposition to our budget agreement before we reached a budget agreement. i was frustrated, too, but i think these are very important elements of our conservative family. i would prefer to keep those within the family. >> i couldn't believe patty murray's face there watching him. one said he was sorry boehner took the whole thing public. look how these guys are going over to the tea party. >> we all need to be held accountable, but at the same time, you know, politically you ought to be focused on the president and harry reid and those kind of fo
here's what paul ryan told a wisconsin radio station. by the way, here he is talking back home which is important. here he is not exactly backing up his leader. >> i don't think it's that serious. i think john got -- his emotions got ahead of him a little bit. i credit the tea party with helping us get our mojo back. getting conservativism back in the party. >> here's a paul ryan skipping off the reservation here. c >> i think john got his irish up. he was frustrated that...
182
182
Oct 17, 2013
10/13
by
FOXNEWSW
tv
eye 182
favorite 0
quote 1
paul ryan voted against this little deal that they just done. i wondered why. i think one good guess would be precisely to preserve his credibility with thing right of the house gop conference to show that he's going in to this negotiation as one of them, as somebody who understands their side. >> i think the consensus is that speaker boehner is going to hold on to power, he's done a good job of listening to different faction, and they haven't come out of the wood work against him. but what about the republicans overall on this day after, licking their wounds and kind of trying to see what lies ahead? >> well, i think you're right. boehner will hold on. he will hold on the his job. i'm not sure he'll hold on to any power because he clearly doesn't have any. he cannot control his caucus. so i think everybody credits him with trying extremely hard to hold it together. he did put up a good fight. i'm not sure it was a wise fight. but in the end, obama says nobody won. you know, that's like sake at appomattox nobody won. it was a great defeat. there's one truth tha
paul ryan voted against this little deal that they just done. i wondered why. i think one good guess would be precisely to preserve his credibility with thing right of the house gop conference to show that he's going in to this negotiation as one of them, as somebody who understands their side. >> i think the consensus is that speaker boehner is going to hold on to power, he's done a good job of listening to different faction, and they haven't come out of the wood work against him. but...